(Updated) Weekly Rankings Update: Builder’s Challenge N°2 – Week 3+4 ⭐

[TSBCreators]

Dear Creators,

As we reveal the revised rankings for week 3 and 4 of the Builders’ Challenge, we want to address any potential remaining questions and ensure transparency regarding the event. We understand that with each update, the community’s attention turns to the fairness and integrity of the rankings, and we want to provide clarity on how we handle these matters.

We have conducted reviews of the current standings and the various strategies used by participants. As part of this process, we have removed some experiences from the rankings in accordance with the event rules. In other cases, we did not find sufficient grounds to remove the experiences in question. While the methods employed by some creators may be unique, they fall within the scope of our current event rules. We recognize, however, that the tools and resources available to us at this time have limitations in fully addressing every aspect of event fairness.

To address this, we want to be upfront that the rules and tools for this Builders’ Challenge will remain unchanged for the remainder of the event. Looking ahead, we recognize that maintaining fairness and transparency is important to uphold the trust and enthusiasm of our community. Therefore, we will engage more closely with you to refine and adjust the rules and processes for future challenges. We appreciate your feedback and insights in our efforts to shape the Builders’ Challenge that best reflects our shared values as a community and organisation. Our goal is to ensure that every participant not only trusts in the fairness of the event but also feels genuinely inspired to contribute their best work.

We also remind and encourage you to use this form to report any suspicious activity in experiences participating in the Builders’ Challenge.

Please Note: Due to recent adjustments concerning duplicate/template experiences, some ranks and scores may appear incorrect. Although these experiences retain their original rankings, other experiences are not affected and may move up, resulting in some scores being higher than those listed above them.
If you have any questions or require further clarification, we are happy to elaborate.

You may also visit our original statement which explains this in more detail.

Thank you for your understanding and continued engagement.

[TSBCreators]

Experience	Creator	Score	Details (Boosters - AVG playtime - Visits)
1 Gatsmania: Builder Wars	TheStockerGATS	96,685	- - - 00:26:51 - 1440
2 Trendy Factory - New Day	Gikis	91,446	- - 00:26:09 - 1749
3 GEOMETRY UPRISING	PANDAYMetaStudio	78,012	- - 00:12:31 - 3115
4 Mastering Kitchen Rush Hour	TobiNCraft	65,792	- - 00:06:57 - 4735
5 Gatsmania: Temple Escape	TheStockerGATS	62,620	- - - 00:19:42 - 1271
6 ROBBiLAND	RobbiArt	61,755	- 01:12:04 - 857
7 Floating Haven	Sandja	59,926	- - 00:08:19 - 3604
8 DONUT PLAY	VauxMachinaStudios	59,250	- - - 00:23:07 - 1025
9 Gatsmania: Giants	TheStockerGATS	57,228	- - - 00:20:17 - 1129
10 Hong Kong Walker: Kowloon Walled City	HKINDEXGAME	56,305	- 01:03:07 - 892
11 YourVerse 1.5M Builders Challenge	YourVerse	36,073	- - - 00:22:48 - 633
12 SHADOWS UNTOLD: TRAIL BUILDER	LUCIDITYUK	33,246	- - 00:23:47 - 699
13 Funguy Frenzy by Tuschay Studios	TuschayStudios	33,038	- - 00:03:53 - 4254
14 SHROOM BOOM by Tuschay Studios	TuschayStudios	32,256	- - 00:46:37 - 346
15 One Last Chance S2​:black_joker:(Lion City Legends!)	theinternX	28,318	- - 01:32:33 - 153
16 Alokin Arena	SirAlokin	27,598	- - - 01:00:39 - 182
17 Lumpinee Boxing Verse	lpnboxingverse	27,324	- 00:15:13 - 1796
18 Area X-08	Happy0101	27,314	- - 00:28:38 - 477
19 Pickaxe Master - Misty Mountain	PickaxeMaster	26,952	- - - 00:47:57 - 281
20 pcwSg’s Treasure Trove	pcwSg	24,723	- - - 02:13:38 - 74
21 Sports Land Manager Legends	HermitMeta	23,014	- 00:11:53 - 1937
22 Orbital Space Rig 89	LittleLegionForgeA	21,843	- - - 00:24:04 - 363
23 Jump Skip Pass	GoWest927	21,528	- - - 00:14:11 - 607
24 SHADOWS UNTOLD: CLOUD RUNNER	LUCIDITYUK	21,072	- - 00:09:35 - 1100
25 Frontier Realms	AlamayaStudios	20,980	- - - 00:13:33 - 619
26 YesChef GJ 2nd [Momo’s Indian Cooking Restaurant]	PGVlab	20,553	- - - 00:04:06 - 2004
27 Clicker Champions Arena	Onesk1pperDev	20,368	- - - 00:12:15 - 665
28 The Lost Desert PVP	Sandsquad	20,333	- - - 00:40:40 - 200
29 Former Trendy Boulder	Gikis	18,765	- - - 00:09:47 - 767
30 MONOCHROME: LAST STAND	TEMPESTstudios	18,456	- - 00:19:16 - 479
31 Tower of Myths: Oldbeel Tavern	AsharaStudios	18,110	- - - 00:24:14 - 299
32 Echo Street (Spot the Difference Game!)	FredandFerd	16,228	- - 00:24:13 - 335
33 RGB Bubble Blaster	Anandjoice	15,630	- - 00:14:24 - 543
34 BINCO COSMIC HUNTERS - PVP	Bincoverse	15,468	- - - 00:24:27 - 253
35 Reggae Golf - The 2nd Round	theJoncrow	15,370	- - 00:08:45 - 879
36 BATTLEGROUND by Smobler	smoblerprojectupsilon	15,303	- - - 00:12:17 - 498
37 Office Rebel	iamnegool	15,175	- - - 00:34:06 - 178
38 SANDBOX LAB - SURVIVOR	pspinw	12,735	- - - 00:18:19 - 278
39 Gatsmania: Jumping Madness	TheStockerGATS	12,344	- - 00:48:59 - 126
40 TRENDY MATCH	Gikis	11,957	- - 00:04:58 - 1606
41 BTC - Blue Tulip Castle	BlueTulip	11,626	- - 00:21:04 - 276
42 Bomkus GJ - Alokin Gamejam Parkour	SirAlokin	11,544	- - 00:31:43 - 182
43 Aeko And Friends: Multi EP.1 Big Mouth Arena	YGRAM	11,458	- - - 00:08:18 - 552
44 Pet’s Kitchen	TomVoxel	11,345	- - - 00:20:32 - 221
45 EAT ! PigPong	zzangddoru	11,194	- - 00:09:23 - 596
46 Kravir	Pocket Camp	rockbu	10,719
47 briusius75 landTSB	killer07	10,160	- - - 00:36:17 - 112
48 Tower of Myths: Colosseum	AsharaStudios	10,143	- - 00:31:27 - 215
49 Gatsmania: Deathrun	TheStockerGATS	10,114	- - 00:33:29 - 151
50 TOKENWARS. DUST ed.	Vilaincoincoin	10,090	- - - 00:09:08 - 442
51 Cryptic Escape: The Sewer	HKINDEXGAME	10,066	- - 00:57:12 - 88
52 The Great Wall Runner	HKINDEXGAME	9,828	- - 00:41:18 - 119
53 RENAULT 5 - R5VOLUTION RACE	bembuilders	9,648	- - - 00:06:16 - 769
54 Gatsmania: World of Gatsumons	TheStockerGATS	9,432	- - 00:28:35 - 165
55 Moca GJ - [ColorRun]	iamCC	8,489	- 01:09:01 - 123
56 The Worst Game Ever!	TuschayStudios	8,318	- - - 00:53:40 - 62
57 GLDN HAUT SHOT	Au24KAY	7,945	- - - 00:18:48 - 169
58 WALLHUGGER	TEMPESTstudios	7,743	- - - 00:08:59 - 345
59 ROACH UPRISING	GreatRworksStudio	7,674	- 00:23:03 - 222
60 MONOCHROME: MAYHEM	TEMPESTstudios	7,350	- - 00:11:21 - 324
61 ATLAS - Mission Run	PGmetaverseOG	7,068	- - - 00:23:22 - 121
62 Wild Harvest: Nature’s Bounty	GureumStudio	6,920	- - 00:29:50 - 116
63 Paris City Jam - All-in Paris!	LastYearTryer	6,796	- - 00:21:39 - 157
64 istanbul 2124 AhuraxArt v 1.0.10	Ahurax	6,464	- - 00:33:19 - 97
65 Pomeverse	smoblerpomevillage	6,428	- - - 00:16:50 - 191
66 Path to Glory!	PuzzleBros	6,327	- - 00:13:55 - 303
67 RUN ! PandaPong *	zzangddoru	6,219	- 00:02:35 - 1600
68 Tower of Myths : Genbu’s Travel	AsharaStudios	6,198	- - 00:17:36 - 176
69 Sands of Sisyphus	BobreDobreStudio	6,156	- - 00:19:59 - 154
70 Clicker Champions	Onesk1pperDev	5,833	- - - 00:17:57 - 130
71 Color Dash	hallugram	5,680	- - - 00:22:03 - 103
72 GLDN HAUT SHOT	Au24KAY	5,670	- - 00:21:00 - 135
73 Cryptic Cauldron	Pandapops	5,220	- - 00:28:41 - 91
74 Temporal Storm Arena	Nirvex74	5,015	- - - 00:12:23 - 162
74 TOKENWARS. SHOOT-OUT ed.	Vilaincoincoin	5,043	- - - 00:09:53 - 204
75 Button Of Chance - SP	EscapeRoomArtist	4,950	- - 00:29:07 - 85
76 Blue Tulip Downkour	BlueTulip	4,903	- - - 00:24:49 - 79
77 Moneyland by Koinsquare	Moneyland	4,652	- - 00:10:16 - 302
78 RUN ! PandaPong 2 *	zzangddoru	4,278	- - 00:07:52 - 272
79 Aeko And Friends: EP.7 Crazy ride of Skull Santa	YGRAM	4,236	- - 00:14:13 - 149
79 TOKENWARS. LIGHT-FIGHT ed.	Vilaincoincoin	4,508	- - - 00:09:26 - 191
80 Cosmic Chaos	Sandja	4,136	- - 00:22:00 - 94
81 TB: Tower Builders	MicrogamE	4,100	- - - 00:18:51 - 87
82 Seb’s Dream: The Olympic	green23	4,038	- - - 00:17:00 - 95
83 Istanbul2124: War For The Throne	AHMETYILMAZ	3,998	- - - 00:15:52 - 126
84 SUMMER GJ - TikTok - True Or False	pspinw	3,890	- - - 00:15:24 - 101
85 BoopGoopHub	BoopGoop	3,800	- - 00:26:46 - 71
86 SCRAPS	BagOGames	3,644	- - - 00:21:11 - 86
87 TSB_Dust2_Paris	TSBGamker	3,585	- - - 00:06:21 - 226
88 Funguy Family Fort - Day (Single-Player)	TuschayStudios	3,553	- 00:30:54 - 115
89 Rolling Boulders	BobreDobreStudio	3,523	- - - 00:18:47 - 75
90 Seb’s Dream: Pepe Seb	green23	3,333	- - - 00:32:31 - 41
91 Care Rail Co	Mangudai	3,244	- - 00:08:40 - 187
92 The Metaclubber	themetaclubber	3,218	- - 00:28:44 - 56
93 Cryptic Escape: The Laboratory	HKINDEXGAME	3,218	- - 01:54:56 - 14
94 MOCA ID GIVEAWAY CODE SEARCH!	DarckinITA	3,213	- - - 00:44:19 - 29
95 EnomisEno’s NFT Gallery	EnomisEno	3,189	- - 00:26:15 - 81
96 Battle Pugs: The Tides of Change by HighsGamingHub	HighsGamingHub	3,154	- - - 00:25:02 - 63
97 SAND Grab Stadium - Season 2	Shakesbeer	3,105	- - - 00:22:11 - 56
98 AtmosCube	lifemademe	3,072	- - 00:06:26 - 239
99 PGFF Community Plaza by PlayGame4Fun V0.0.3	PlayGame4FunYT	3,043	- - - 00:18:43 - 65
100 Element PVP	dramahot	2,865	- - - 00:18:11 - 63
101 TSB_Estate (Lion City Template by @digital_dalang)	theinternX	2,850	- - - 00:34:45 - 41
102 Venus Fashion	matvoxel	2,835	- - 00:31:30 - 60
103 Exorcist: Reborn	AsharaStudios	2,760	- - 00:47:35 - 29
104 SUMMER GJ - Pattern Block - Game Jam	dramahot	2,723	- - - 00:12:40 - 86
105 Space Fighting [Hard Mode]	myrealitydao	2,625	- - 00:05:44 - 305
106 Iced plants…	Mirosh054	2,523	- - - 00:11:20 - 89
107 SandTopia Social Club BASSment (STSC)	iantheitguy	2,498	- - - 00:13:53 - 72
108 Wicked Hub	Wickedu	2,323	- - - 00:20:12 - 46
109 Tower of Myths	AsharaStudios	2,286	- 00:27:13 - 56
110 Trade with Granny	Alihr	2,284	- - 00:25:57 - 44
111 MetaHKDI - Cultural & Creative Hub	metaCampusHKDI	2,180	- - - 00:32:04 - 34
112 Maradona Ascension	HermitMeta	2,114	- - 01:18:17 - 18
113 Desolate Island	lambdo87	2,094	- - - 00:10:35 - 99
114 3VEREST	The Edge	everest3xsmobler	1,976
115 CryptoMarco Island	0xCryptoMarco	1,948	- - - 00:08:51 - 88
116 Ink Astro	Paklos	1,943	- - - 00:09:22 - 83
117 AURAVERSE - Chapter 0: The Rift	tr4ncegames	1,900	- - 00:12:40 - 75
118 GODDEXX: THE CYBER MYTH	nftbiennial	1,851	- - 00:07:01 - 176
119 Galactic Clash	ImpossibleDreamStudio	1,808	- - - 00:07:52 - 115
120 The Valley of Belonging 2024	hcpoc2023	1,762	- - - 02:39:36 - 10
121 100 Logos Quiz	bembuilders	1,686	- - - 00:18:44 - 45
122 Warrior’s Run	joe5117crip258	1,658	- - - 00:11:38 - 57
123 Take Back the Night	SSDW	1,610	- - - 00:12:38 - 51
124 Pandonian Race Maze	Pandapops2	1,595	- - - 00:19:58 - 33
125 Seb’s Dream: Idol Maker	green23	1,588	- - 00:16:33 - 48
125 Dante’s Inferno Defenders	theinternX	1,654	- - - 00:21:46 - 38
126 GOGOGO Boys and Girls	aakuuiak100	1,585	- - - 00:03:06 - 205
127 The Island Isolated	HitunaMo	1,576	- - - 00:26:16 - 30
127 TOKENFIELD RETRO ed.	Vilaincoincoin	1,600	- - 00:29:38 - 27
128 HAPPITAT - THE LION CITY	SINGAPORE SOCIAL HUB	Happitat	1,488
129 Farm House Fun	theinternX	1,434	- - - 00:24:43 - 29
130 Exorcist: Kai’s Nightmare	AsharaStudios	1,418	- 00:16:53 - 56
131 [Renewed] Aeko And Friends: EP.3 Clock Tower	YGRAM	1,407	- 00:12:02 - 78
132 The Bank Job	A Quickfire Arcade Heist	LoaLoaGames	1,357
133 Le Louvre Letters	addy2045	1,328	- - 00:30:11 - 22
133 Backyard Crafting	theinternX	1,481	- - 00:29:55 - 33
134 [Renewed] Aeko And Friends: EP.1 Number Maze	YGRAM	1,280	- 00:09:42 - 132
135 DUCKY ARMORY	Vilaincoincoin	1,259	- - 00:28:56 - 29
136 Cyber Circlet - Dragon’s Lava Lair	FACBROS	1,238	- - 00:04:50 - 128
137 Lion City Gallery by @digital_dalang	theinternX	1,220	- - - 00:20:20 - 30
137 Your Fishing Adventure Begins!	theinternX	1,365	- - 00:32:30 - 28
138 Pass the Virus	theinternX	1,216	- - - 00:21:43 - 28
139 TOKENFIELD ed. FAIRY	Vilaincoincoin	1,173	- 00:35:33 - 22
140 Natural Disaster Chaos	1fa6sad5	1,168	- - - 00:03:04 - 152
140 Miner’s Rush!	theinternX	1,293	- - 00:24:38 - 35
141 Lucky ME - Bomkus Jr.	YtsejamGame	1,152	- - 02:08:00 - 6
142 The Necromancer’s Dungeon	rockbu	1,140	- - 00:08:07 - 72
143 Aeko And Friends: EP.6 Clown’s giftbox	YGRAM	1,126	- - 00:09:05 - 62
144 The Dragon’s Nest	theinternX	1,097	- - 00:13:17 - 55
145 HUB - Slay the Hidden Dragon	GoWest927	1,038	- - - 00:10:38 - 39
146 The Lost Spaceship	theinternX	1,036	- - - 00:17:16 - 30
146 Climb Climb Climb!	theinternX	1,214	- - - 00:21:41 - 28
147 Moca Moca Keep Jumping!	OldwonLululand	1,008	- - 00:28:00 - 24
148 Racing One [NEW]	bembuilders	1,006	- - - 00:18:38 - 27
149 Atlantis - The Lost Kingdom	TWW Collection	ERMLABS	999
150 Game Maker Trick Test	Randag1o	984	- - 00:07:27 - 88
151 Off the Ground 2124	erginyanar	982	- - - 00:24:33 - 20
152 The Apawcalypse	ImpossibleDreamStudio	960	- - 00:13:20 - 36
153 Gameland version 2	EscapeRoomArtist	958	- - - 00:13:12 - 29
153 Buidl to Survive!	theinternX	1,067	- - 00:25:24 - 28
154 Gameland Corrupted version 2	EscapeRoomArtist	943	- - - 00:15:05 - 25
155 Pit Run	GoWest927	935	- - - 00:06:41 - 56
156 Funguy Family Fort - Night (Multiplayer)	TuschayStudios	933	- - 00:12:58 - 48
157 MULTI MOONBOOK	Vilaincoincoin	898	- - - 00:16:02 - 28
158 SheInspires GJ - Sanctuary of Inspiration	theinternX	888	- - 00:17:56 - 33
159 AK47hat’s House	AK47hat	884	- - 00:10:31 - 42
159 Scary House in the Valley	theinternX	992	- - - 00:17:43 - 28
160 OLC (中文/拼音版)	theinternX	857	- - 00:18:25 - 31
161 Putt Putt Pass	BoopGoop	816	- - 00:34:00 - 12
162 BOMKUS AEROLAB	Vilaincoincoin	802	- - 00:18:14 - 22
163 -SUBVOX-	theJoncrow	790	- - 00:24:41 - 16
164 Use your brain!	sopw2000	768	- - - 00:01:53 - 163
164 TOKENFIELD ed. CLASSIC	Vilaincoincoin	954	- 00:27:39 - 23
165 Aeko And Friends: EP.8 Crazy Skull Ferris Wheel	YGRAM	765	- - 00:08:14 - 62
166 Proud to Love in Paris	LoveinParisGame	746	- - 05:36:30 - 2
167 Go! Go! Dragon Boat	HKINDEXGAME	738	- - 00:41:27 - 9
168 Tower of Myths: Arkane Bestiary	AsharaStudios	720	- - 00:10:35 - 34
168 Jumping Jumperoon	theinternX	928	- - - 00:20:10 - 23
169 Cooking Clash (Season 1)	myrealitydao	716	- - 00:47:42 - 10
169 Hunt for the Missing Relic (Beaver Trouble)	theinternX	920	- - - 00:16:26 - 28
170 PANtopia	pantopia	713	- - 00:21:18 - 24
170 Survive the Apocalyse!	theinternX	899	- - 00:18:43 - 32
171 Heart of the Mountain	Kotofeika	666	- - 00:31:43 - 14
172 Justforfun!	Rezizi	665	- - - 00:01:35 - 168
173 Tower of Myths: Monster Chef	AsharaStudios	653	- - - 00:13:03 - 20
174 Wizzy the Purple’s Spider Ark	KamiSawZe	653	- - - 00:05:20 - 49
174 Pirate Ship Hunters	theinternX	880	- - - 00:16:18 - 27
175 Adventure park	Alihr	643	- - - 00:08:52 - 29
175 MOONBOOK RUN	Vilaincoincoin	872	- - 00:16:46 - 26
176 RichClub	a8lpq02s8	642	- - - 00:01:51 - 173
177 template stock assets with MOB PVE	Happy0101	638	- - - 02:39:30 - 2
177 Metaverse Central Casino	theinternX	831	- - 00:19:06 - 29
178 UFO Showdown - Qualifiers - Alpha Test	Shakesbeer	618	- - 00:10:39 - 29
179 Night Club Terror	theinternX	555	- - 00:14:48 - 25
180 Eddie Smokey’s Day	sebga	551	- - 00:20:23 - 18
181 Rings Gaming	pf5s8az2	535	- - - 00:01:13 - 177
181 Gamble Away!	theinternX	777	- - 00:17:16 - 30
182 Obby Race to the Top	Jaydogg	533	- - - 00:09:16 - 23
183 Krafterverse Hub	Krafter	516	- - - 00:10:19 - 25
184 Competitive Overwatch Relay Team Experience CORTEX	SandCastler	512	- - - 00:09:51 - 26
185 SP 3C Squad GYM - 0.10.6	1B0Xt	504	- 00:17:41 - 19
186 MLM Pyramid of Doom!	SandCastler	499	- 00:45:22 - 11
186 Galleria House	theinternX	726	- - 00:17:17 - 28
187 Siege Defense : Wrath of the Titans!	theinternX	477	- 00:17:02 - 28
188 To the Moon 2	snd5c2d5x	466	- - - 00:01:28 - 159
189 NFT Gallery Experience	tryer	431	- - 00:26:05 - 11
190 HODLHil’s Hearts	HODLHil	430	- - - 00:09:03 - 19
191 Yes Chef GJ - Cooker	Shakesbeer	428	- - 00:09:44 - 22
192 Pandara Poolvilla Cha am	AK47hat	426	- - 00:11:22 - 25
193 Color Catch	YtsejamGame	423	- - 00:23:30 - 12
194 New Born - Retribution	YtsejamGame	407	- - 00:19:21 - 14
195 ROG Chapter 1: The Prophecy	RealmOfGods	402	- - 00:11:39 - 23
196 Manifesto	Walronius	384	- - 00:14:46 - 13
197 People are electricity	NoeJeol	384	- - 00:17:27 - 11
197 AEROLAB ESCAPE	Vilaincoincoin	638	- - 00:13:52 - 23
198 Paris City Jam - [MOMO’s Louvre Museum]	PGVlab	372	- - - 00:06:12 - 30
199 WondersBook Chapter 2 : Path of the Unknown	TigerLilyCat	372	- - 00:13:17 - 14
199 The Great HK Rollup	theinternX	608	- - 00:13:30 - 30
200 Tales of Pixlton	Pixlton	353	- - 00:39:10 - 6
200 SNIPER WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	568	- - - 00:12:21 - 23
201 Dysto GN HUB	Sandsquad	350	- - 01:00:20 - 3
202 Loop Town - Chapter 1	YtsejamGame	348	- 02:54:00 - 2
203 Portal Rush - Race for the Seventh Crystal	TomVoxel	345	- - 00:15:20 - 15
204 Destroy Enemies	d5555sx	340	- - - 00:00:47 - 175
205 The Legend of The Miners	MetaFuturaStudio	321	- 00:45:51 - 7
206 PuningCityVer	9988ww01op	320	- - - 00:01:10 - 138
207 THE OMPHALOS - TITAN REIGN	TEMPESTstudios	317	- - 00:52:45 - 4
208 IMAGINARIUM	Frenemyverse	311	- 01:43:40 - 3
209 Loading Time Empty Experience	Ponter	309	- - 00:22:53 - 9
209 ASSAULT RIFLE WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	478	- - - 00:09:58 - 24
210 Cyber Circlet - Bones and Chicken of the Desert	FACBROS	304	- - 00:10:51 - 14
211 3VEREST	The Wall	everest3xsmobler	300
212 Annual National Forum by VBA	myrealitydao	300	- - 00:15:23 - 13
212 SNIPER WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	448	- - - 00:09:44 - 23
213 Cuisinia Cutlery Feast	archopia	282	- - 00:09:54 - 19
213 SHOTGUN WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	440	- - - 00:08:09 - 27
214 Jump jump jump it!!	we5ee8ea	278	- - - 00:00:40 - 165
215 KOC PakPak HopHop	KOCWarrior	267	- 00:09:12 - 29
216 Cyber Circlet - Simulated Menace: Alien Hatchery	FACBROS	250	- - 00:08:56 - 14
217 MONOCHROME: MONOLITH	TEMPESTstudios	245	- - 00:32:36 - 5
218 [22 Yards GJ 3rd place] Cricket Last War	PGVlab	244	- - - 00:04:04 - 30
219 Go Fighing	55g2d0s2a	240	- - - 00:00:34 - 169
219 PANDABOOM WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	408	- - - 00:08:30 - 24
220 Ninja Kingdom	KyoseiBank	233	- - 00:05:58 - 26
221 Loop Town Reinitialize - Chapter 2	YtsejamGame	228	- - 00:19:00 - 8
221 SEB RIFLE WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	406	- - - 00:08:07 - 25
222 YesChef GJ - BeChef	BlueTeam	214	- - - 00:08:14 - 13
223 Ingenium: An Engineering Exploration	DrMetaverso	212	- - 00:35:20 - 3
224 Survival Snowboarding	SparkySnikle	212	- 00:08:29 - 25
225 Ruby and Emerald	AndyGraga	208	- - - 00:34:45 - 4
226 Catstanbul2124 - Istanbul2124 GJ	peanut11	197	- - 00:07:42 - 17
227 Hezarfen’s Legacy	CloudMonkey	194	- - 00:01:32 - 84
228 Recycle Center / Build Eco-City	PGVlab	192	- - 00:04:34 - 28
229 Follow the green line	Stalakirth	188	- - 00:09:20 - 18
230 TheBackspace World	TheBackspace	186	- - - 00:18:36 - 5
231 Bomkus GJ_ Space Adventure	PGVlab	179	- - 00:04:58 - 24
232 Metaverse Japan	KyoseiBank	174	- - - 00:14:30 - 6
233 HousePA	r0154s855	172	- - - 00:00:28 - 182
234 玻璃博物馆	zdk0555	168	- - - 00:00:33 - 155
235 Oh Nasi Lemak	MuseGenie2	161	- - 00:35:40 - 3
236 Floor Droppers by MetaWorlds and Metatheory Studio	Lanzrr	161	- - 00:37:40 - 3
237 Gnomes vs Knights	NotAnimated	150	- - 00:03:51 - 26
238 Trouble Down Under Part 1 - Season 2	Roofue	149	- - 00:03:32 - 28
239 The Art of Runway	bembuilders	148	- - - 00:12:20 - 6
240 Horror Mansion [Midnight Escape: Monster Room]	PGVlab	140	- 00:04:40 - 30
241 Pandonian Fun-Fair	Pandapops2	140	- - - 00:11:12 - 5
242 AfterOcean : Canisty Run	FACBROS	140	- - 00:13:17 - 7
243 CURAÇAO METAVERSE	CuracaoMetaverse	138	- - 00:07:05 - 13
244 Backrooms GJ - Orbital 51	Shakesbeer	138	- 00:04:27 - 31
245 Madball Only Up!	PGVlab	137	- - 00:03:08 - 29
246 Summer Splash	VauxMachinaStudios	136	- - - 00:13:36 - 5
247 Story of Yuko	DAPPCRAFT	134	- 03:21:00 - 2
247 BERETTA WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	238	- - - 00:04:24 - 27
248 CARGO CONTAINER SCI-FI & DYSTOPIAN CITY	coteli	134	- - 00:11:08 - 8
249 Moca GJ - Space Battle	MetaguruTeam	129	- - 00:06:09 - 14
250 LKY100 Tribute Exhibition	lky100smobler	128	- - 00:10:38 - 8
250 CYBER RIFLE WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	222	- - - 00:05:03 - 22
251 Eurostellar 2024	bembuilders	128	- - 00:08:30 - 10
251 SHOTGUN WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	220	- - - 00:04:47 - 23
252 Thronefall Care Bears Tower Defense	PGVlab	119	- - 00:03:10 - 25
252 ASSAULT RIFLE WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	216	- - - 00:04:19 - 25
253 FOOTBALL SHOOTOUT!	PuzzleBros	117	- 00:16:43 - 7
254 SUMMER GJ - Engineer	HappyGamer22	117	- - 00:05:34 - 14
255 rare abyss hunter	01a1	116	- - 00:15:24 - 5
256 PlayPan 2.0	SandCastler	116	- - 00:12:50 - 6
257 Echoes of Past	ierkal	114	- - 00:01:02 - 73
257 SEB RIFLE WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	206	- - - 00:04:29 - 23
258 HODLhil’s Metaverse Marbles!	SandZeus	113	- - - 00:22:30 - 2
258 PANDABOOM WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	206	- - - 00:04:41 - 22
259 Festival of Pride	PeopleOfCrypto	102	- - 06:14:00 - 1
259 AK47 WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	202	- - - 00:04:23 - 23
260 PlanetZ – Speed Run competition - Virtual Mall	PlanetZ	95	- - 00:07:53 - 8
260 WINCHESTER WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	198	- - - 00:04:18 - 23
261 City Jam Paris Le Louvre	sebga	95	- - 00:31:30 - 2
262 A Love is Forever	LuluLand2021	86	- - - 00:08:36 - 5
262 UZI WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	194	- - - 00:04:03 - 24
263 HODL Island	HODLHil	86	- - 00:08:36 - 5
264 Physics Town Mayhem	theinternX	82	- - - 00:04:33 - 9
265 Cyber Circlet Labs	FACBROS	80	- - - 00:16:00 - 2
266 Tom Yum Planet: The Secrets of Authentic Flavor	DevAbyKantana	78	- - 00:13:00 - 4
267 AULA7	Dankoyy	78	- - - 00:06:30 - 6
268 MetaPastry LAB V2	Schwarzengel0076	73	- - - 00:14:30 - 2
268 BERETTA WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	176	- - - 00:03:23 - 26
269 Impact GJ - Planet Sand	green23	72	- - 00:59:00 - 1
270 Battle Sub’s	Sandman7	70	- - - 00:04:40 - 6
271 MP 3C GYM NFTA	1B0Xt	70	- - 00:00:27 - 77
271 CYBER RIFLE WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	168	- - - 00:03:39 - 23
272 Furry Haven	lotpet	68	- - - 00:04:51 - 7
273 Get Off My Lawn	IBGigglin	65	- - 00:03:04 - 14
274 ICE CREAM SAVE THE METAVERSE	LuluLand2021	65	- - 00:07:10 - 6
275 This is for you wahpaks	green23	62	- - 00:05:51 - 7
275 COMMANDO RIFFLE WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	160	- - - 00:03:38 - 22
276 Boop Tower Defence	BoopGoop	60	- - 00:06:00 - 5
276 UZI WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	154	- - - 00:03:40 - 21
277 Space Fighting	myrealitydao	60	- - 00:02:21 - 17
278 The Rooster Calls	HKINDEXGAME	56	- - 00:18:30 - 2
278 WINCHESTER WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	150	- - - 00:03:00 - 25
279 Odyssey Elements Challenge	TobiNCraft	55	- - - 00:05:30 - 4
280 Deja Vu 2	PuzzleBros	54	- - 00:18:00 - 2
281 Core Guardians TD	MetaguildStudio	54	- - 00:06:00 - 6
282 Battleship Passage	green23	53	- - 00:35:00 - 1
283 Paris City Jam - Arcane Triumph: The Paths of Time	CerTaj026	51	- - 00:04:15 - 8
284 Paris City Jam - Paris Walk around	Biagi	50	- - - 00:04:10 - 6
285 Paris City Jam - Paris Adventure Quest	Hajik	48	- - 00:06:24 - 5
286 Drum IT	xummer	47	- - 00:15:30 - 2
287 Shuttle Paris	MuseGenie2	47	- - 00:06:12 - 5
288 Louvre Guardians	myrealitydao	44	- - - 00:02:27 - 9
289 The Sandbox - Product Meeting	DrakeMRC	44	- - - 00:04:24 - 5
290 Seaside Fashion Fest	Sandja	42	- - 00:07:00 - 3
290 AK47 WORLD	Vilaincoincoin	132	- - - 00:03:00 - 22
291 SongWon	gostory	41	- - 00:01:00 - 27
291 COMMANDO RIFFLE WORLD FPS	Vilaincoincoin	130	- - - 00:02:57 - 22
292 BINCO FORBIDDEN HARVEST	Bincoverse	40	- 00:10:00 - 4
293 USBONG HIRAYA GJ - CARABAO RACE	NFTwoojuin	38	- - 00:04:45 - 4
294 Riding Shooter	HKINDEXGAME	38	- - 00:03:34 - 7
295 The Last Pizza Run	MH8D	33	- - - 00:04:20 - 3
296 MetaHKDI	metaCampusHKDI	32	- - - 00:03:12 - 5
297 Test(0701-1)	UOVAMETA	32	- - 00:04:12 - 5
298 Lava Defense by MetaWorlds and DreamJunk Studios	MetaWorldsMeta1	30	- - 00:01:26 - 14
299 TAG_d2	Dankoyy	30	- - - 00:05:00 - 6
300 Met’Artistic	campusstmarc	24	- - 00:16:00 - 1
301 Pickaxe Master - Temple of the Four Winds	PickaxeMaster	24	- - - 00:06:00 - 2
302 Astro Archaeologist Arena	Sandja	24	- - 00:04:00 - 3
303 HKDI Arena	metaCampusHKDI	24	- - 00:05:20 - 3
304 Blinx Amphitheatre	BharatboxOfficial	24	- - - 00:03:00 - 4
305 Fire Hunters	campusstmarc	24	- - 00:03:12 - 5
306 SOS Pyramid	meaningone	23	- 00:23:00 - 1
307 Paris City Jam - CAPTURE PARIS	NFTwoojuin	23	- - 00:02:30 - 6
308 mecoVerse	TheCampus	22	- 00:11:00 - 2
309 AI’stanbul	Masterkedi	21	- - 00:01:45 - 8
310 Deep Sea	DeepseaYobike	21	- 00:04:48 - 5
311 My ApartmentPAPA	bigPaPa888	21	- 00:03:30 - 4
312 Mana Chillin	Rabbistar	20	- - - 00:01:40 - 6
313 Rotomagus 1.0	campusstmarc	20	- - 00:06:30 - 2
314 Waiting game…	TomVoxel	20	- - 00:06:30 - 2
315 Obby Gooey	MuseGenie2	20	- - 00:01:38 - 8
316 Backroom Game Jam - Alice’s Room	GureumStudio	19	- 00:03:48 - 5
317 STEAMWiseHK	steamwisehk	18	- - - 00:00:45 - 12
318 Tropical Delights–A Playboy Game Jam Adventure	Sapperlight	18	- 00:18:00 - 1
319 Island Boro ART NFT experience	boroartnft	18	- - - 00:09:00 - 1
320 OASIS8_Museum #884	oasis8	18	- - - 00:04:30 - 2
321 VIKING ASSAULT 1.0	campusstmarc	17	- - 00:02:45 - 4
322 AfterOcean: Adventure Pink	FACBROS	17	- - 00:01:50 - 6
323 Forever Oasis	lifemademe	15	- 00:10:00 - 1
324 Bomkus Game Jam - Skull King	MetaguruTeam	15	- - 00:00:26 - 23
325 SUMMER GJ - Click to Fame: Marina Melodies	MuseGenie2	14	- - 00:09:00 - 1
326 testing luckyfisher temaplte	KrampusTSB	14	- - 00:09:00 - 1
327 M (10) (1)	Harexz	12	- - - 00:01:30 - 4
328 Muddy Barbarian Obstacle Course	Sapperlight	12	- - 00:08:00 - 1
329 Khan Kluay The Adventure of Friendship	DevAbyKantana	12	- 00:01:43 - 7
330 FTW (1.1)	Wickedu	12	- 00:04:00 - 2
331 The GameBuddy Forge	NotAnimated	12	- - 00:02:00 - 4
332 fALLING tO vICTORY!!	jarjarjackiechanbinks	11	- 00:03:40 - 3
333 City Rescue 1.0	campusstmarc	11	- - 00:13:00 - 1
334 Care Factory Co.	Mangudai	11	- 00:07:00 - 1
335 Tiny Toy Defender	Sandja	11	- 00:21:00 - 1
336 AstroWalk	SandCastler	10	- - - 00:02:30 - 2
337 Food Rescue World	GoGoBox2022	10	- - - 00:02:30 - 2
338 C32 Office	c32	10	- - - 00:05:00 - 1
339 The Clock Quest 1.0	campusstmarc	9	- - 00:03:00 - 2
340 IMPACT GJ - Mayor’s Quest	Hajik	9	- - 00:02:00 - 3
341 Paris City Jam - The Louvre puzzle	yuriybx	9	- - 00:03:00 - 2
342 RUN! RAT! RUN!	MetaFuturaStudio	9	- 00:01:48 - 5
343 Multivers 1.0	campusstmarc	9	- - 00:03:00 - 2
344 CARE BEARS and The Rainbow Tower Guardian	MetaFuturaStudio	9	- 00:03:00 - 3
345 Street Burst	myrealitydao	9	- - 00:00:30 - 12
346 METAVERS INSADONG	digiclon	9	- - 00:02:00 - 3
347 binkies farm 2024	Boosky	8	- 00:01:36 - 5
348 Crypto Night Club	0xCryptoMarco	8	- 00:02:30 - 2
349 SHADOWS UNTOLD - BIRD BLASTER	LUCIDITYUK	8	- - 00:05:00 - 1
350 Pirates Vs Pirates	MetaFuturaStudio	8	- - 00:02:30 - 2
351 BuddhaLand The One	WaterMinnie	6	- - 00:01:30 - 2
352 BONES BUSTER	MetaFuturaStudio	6	- 00:02:00 - 3
353 Future Pursuit	Drie42	6	- - 00:04:00 - 1
354 Star Billionaire	SCB10X	6	- - 00:02:00 - 2
355 My NFT Gallery 0.1.3	ceramisturk	6	- - 00:01:20 - 3
356 Deep Sea: Chapter 0	DeepseaYobike	5	- 00:05:00 - 1
357 SU MAIN TEST 26jun	LUCIDITYUK	5	- - 00:03:00 - 1
358 My first steps.	Dicebow	5	- - 00:01:30 - 2
359 Hmmm…	Happy0101	5	- - 00:01:30 - 2
360 PIZZA-MAN	METAFUTURISTA	5	- - 00:03:00 - 1
361 LaurieG’s NFT Art Gallery.	LaurieG	4	- - 00:01:00 - 2
362 SHOP.D2	iamnegool	4	- - - 00:02:00 - 1
363 THE UNDERWATCH Party	PuzzleBros	3	- - 00:02:00 - 1
364 Paris the city of love	rawraw101	3	- - 00:00:40 - 3
365 Paris City Jam - Eiffel Manager	JRung	3	- - 00:02:00 - 1
366 Doasis X Warrix : Mutiplayer	doasis	3	- 00:01:30 - 2
367 StarCat : Space Delivery Service	Loccle	2	- 00:01:00 - 2
368 Test01 Bosskiller	bosskiller	2	- - 00:00:12 - 5
369 [SANDION] Camel Race	FACBROS	2	- - 00:00:20 - 3

[TobeyU]

@PeaJay wen reward for week 3 and 4

[Gikis]

Trendy Nerds says thank you!

[ENTENIUM]

Although I still don’t agree with GATs taking high ranks (It still feel like we’re robbed!), but thank you we are able to rank up and claim the prize we deserved. At least, from GEOMETRY UPRISING

[DarckinITA]

So little recap.
From 410 experiences we went to 369
Only 41 experiences were removed from the ranking.
First I would like to understand how you can say that an experience is “rigged” compared to one that is not.
I’ll give you an example:
in 14 days I received 180 passes visits, with an average Gameplay amount of 1.30h, the higher the number of visitors the more difficult it is to have an average.

this was expelled ONLY from week 3/4

as you can see ONLY for this week.

Now let’s compare, time, income and above all experience.

78 views is less than half of mine, playtime is almost double mine
Entering the experience in the missions that come out there is this wording as a description “It is not important to complete the mission, you can also stay still”
It’s a labyrinth that can be completed in 20 seconds, without death, without anything at all.
At the end of the map, that is, a few corners ahead… there are NFTs scattered everywhere, without any sense.

Yet it went from 22nd place to number 20
I could put others, but I don’t see why I have to be the one to do the job they should do.
The ranking you have just published is totally wrong from what you read at the end, the scores are not correct and the ranking itself is actually incorrect.
As always you are doing a really bad job, you spend weeks making people think that you are behind checking a ranking 24 hours a day when that is not the case.
There are people who waste time to participate in events that you yourself put out with your rules, only to see themselves thrown out just because you are not able to verify everything.
@PeaJay You don’t write privately warning people that they are at risk for the time they have, and you let others receive direct communication of a BAN of the experience without even asking for information about it.
Be honest, there are barely 1000 players playing, and you’re going to throw out an experience with 180 views… just because you have to pretend to control…

[pcwSg]

At this point i dont know you are trying to get yourself unbanned, or trying to get me banned, but i will still help you say something…

True that receiving the ban hammer (just for 1 round) is quite difficult to swallow, but would have to say that you are just unlucky to be placed 13th on the first LB, in a higher reward tier, so they went harder on you.

Since my experience was commented on, i would have to reply to it…
It may seem like a low effort project to experienced XP makers, but i only decided to start this project days before BC2 started, and this is my first ever XP.

1. “Entering the experience in the missions that come out there is this wording as a description “It is not important to complete the mission, you can also stay still””

-I decided to make quests optional because people who replay may want to skip all the early zones to only try out the newly added zones, which is to help players not waste time on my XP instead of encouraging anyone to waste time staying still on my XP.

2. “It’s a labyrinth that can be completed in 20 seconds”.
   My concept when designing the map is to make a maze which uses up every single block of the map to have the maximum space to cater for mini-games and NFTs, now i have 5 zones and have made the 6th zone which will be released this week… Unfortunately, found out that the Rules page is already at 70% and Variables list is throwing warning messages, so most of the map will remain empty and not utilized due to such constraints… but am optimistic that the maximum load of each XP will improve in future.

3. “At the end of the map, that is, a few corners ahead… there are NFTs scattered everywhere, without any sense.”
   -i do agree that i have no talent for design and art, just putting out all the random NFTs i have collected in the final zone so the makers of the NFTs would have fun spotting their own NFTs.

Lastly, sad to see that you got totally excluded from the LB instead of just having the invalid playtime removed… Instead of reviewing individual XPs and removing invalid playtime (which is doable but not viable), i would recommend suspicious XPs to be given ranking from 369 onwards, so that everyone still gets something for participating instead of being left empty handed, and the prizes for the current list do not need to get delayed further.

[DarckinITA]

I see your point, but it’s not what you think.
I was about to write that in 1 hour after the ranking was released, in 6 hours there was no one writing about the change.
Which is very strange given where the previous post got to.
Between those who blamed the numerous views and the impossible record times, between the studios who said everything about how they treated the community and those who couldn’t wait to see the rewards arrive.
Today I was expecting a further crowd from the release but so far I’m the only one who has written.
I was left waiting for the new rules and new leaderboard when we were near the end of the event, only to find myself with a score that anyone can do.
As you can see I don’t need to do it secretly, if I have something to say I say it publicly so anyone can read it.
Your example should make us reflect on the question of whether it is right or wrong, there are many similar statistics and others that are almost anomalous and trivially understandable e.g.: 1 Entry - 6h average time.
This is rightly good as an experience because it doesn’t reach the TOP so it should be rewarded, but anyone who reaches the TOP and is trivially not part of the Studio or in any case a great creator should be expelled.
TheSandbox put me in that position and TheSandbox took me out of that position.

[DarckinITA]

@TSBCreators

GEOMETRY UPRISING

I also wanted to reply to you dear.
You have 2 accounts, 1 is this one and the other is PANDAYMetaStudioIn week 1/2 you were not present.
You opened the map on July 7th and in 14 days you managed to get more views than all those who are putting up competitions and prizes within the experience.
I wonder how you managed it, what method you used and above all if you will be able to maintain that average, given that from what it seems, from the rankings, the game was going strong.
I’m happy that you managed to climb the rankings, but I also expect that in 5/6 to see you again in the same position.
In case you are not in the same position but rather with a very low number compared to the one you are in now… whoever wants to understand should understand…

[ENTENIUM]

Yes I managed 2 accounts: 1 personal and 1 for the studio. I used the personal ENTENIUM to play any games, and the studio only for studio works. Both accounts are KYC. You’re also correct that my experience went too fast to join the Top ranks with but a little prize pool compared to other studios.

Our metrics was actually doing just good a couple of days after publishing, the game was designed at least 1hr gameplay (start-finish), but we got an avg gameplay of 30min (which is great!) and i think these were coming from #SandFam thru BC raids were I am very active. One thing that boost it was when our experience was included on Featured Experience Of The Week . The AVG gameplay went from 30min to 12min with almost 800 Players playing it everyday. That was overwhelming! I don’t have other ways to promote my game than making use of Twitter post, updating leaderboards everyday and sending replies to my players. I don’t think I will still be able to Rank high after that week because again I haven’t build up a community for myself yet, I only left with players that actually enjoyed playing my game and some wanted to earn 5SAND everyday.

[DarckinITA]

That’s right, in short you achieved that goal because you were in the foreground, it no longer being difficult to reach that quota again.
So let’s go through seeing one of your experiences in TOP just because it was in the foreground, and not seeing it in the next one.
Isn’t that strange?
it’s right to give space to everyone, but it’s not right to exclude without the slightest idea of ​​what you’re doing.
The real numbers are different and you see them all the time, not just one day.

[AndyRichy]

Hey, I have been checking the data provided and noticed the total number of experiences is 412
If you look through the table above some lines have the same position number
For example 2 users I notice - theinternX & Vilaincoincoin their experiences seem to have been effected by this.

Please Note: Due to recent adjustments concerning duplicate/template experiences, some ranks and scores may appear incorrect. Although these experiences retain their original rankings, other experiences are not affected and may move up, resulting in some scores being higher than those listed above them.
If you have any questions or require further clarification, we are happy to elaborate.

Edit Pasted wrong quote -
“Clarification on Duplicate Experiences
We’d like to clarify our approach to duplicated and other “spam” experiences. Existing duplicated experiences and those deemed spam, such as templates or empty LAND, will still be included in the rankings and will receive rewards. However, they will not affect the overall rankings. For example, if a duplicated experience ranks at #30 and your experience is at #31, your experience will be considered #30 in the rankings. Moving forward, any new duplicated or spam experiences will be disqualified. The Sandbox reserves the right to remove experiences from the leaderboard at our discretion if they are considered “spam,” including empty LAND, templates with minimal changes, and duplicates with minor modifications.”

[DarckinITA]

Yes, in fact that’s why I wrote that the ranking is totally wrong.
At first glance it looks like they eliminated about 40 experiences.
But if you count the duplicates, those that have the same number, my data comes out to 406.
There may be experiences that were not previously included in the ranking, in fact in the first 50 there are those who were not listed in the previous ranking, but were present in the 1/2.
So counting the duplicates there are approximately 406 experiences, not counting them comes out 369.
How many have returned now and how many have they really thrown out?
10? (I’m wide)
13 days for 10 experiences? Great work!
We will certainly never know the numbers, because if we have to start doing their job, check experiences because they are not capable as they were not capable of calculating a minimum time in the previous speed run challenge.
I wonder where is the fateful answer “Let’s listen to the community, we have taken action bla bla…”

[theJoncrow]

Thanks for the updated rankings,
and plans for future builders challenges. It feels a bit status quo for the remainder of the challenge, which I get, as the terms of the event were set out from the get go. I dont necessarily agree, but I’m fine with this for the sake of just moving forward. My hope is that we dont lose good builders from this community, and that we all keep providing constructive feedback where and when we see it needed.

I’m glad to hear that more community consultation could be implemented to prevent things like this down the road.

It’ll take a number of iterations to get this right, as there are always going to be outliers, or experiences / builders pressing up against the thresholds of the rules.

On a slightly related note, we have to get tools for leaderboard management rankings. As builders hosting contests and paying out percentages of bc2 earnings all we really have to rely on are screenshots or video, both of which are trivial to fake. Ive got a few ways to detect cheats in the game, but I’m sure i don’t catch all of them.

Leaderboards would quickly take away the simple photoshop/after fx/ nuke cheats, feeding player data to the leaderboards. Granted, there are still in game cheats that players will find, but at least it takes away one more tool on the part of players looking to game your game. Weve had it in the background for a while, but never enabled. I hope this is top of mind in the dev cycle as its a big drain on my time to vet screenshots for contests.

Anyways, just wanted to drop my voice in. Thanks!

[TuschayStudios]

@TSBCreators

We have conducted reviews of the current standings and the various strategies used by participants. As part of this process, we have removed some experiences from the rankings in accordance with the event rules.

If you did indeed catch these participants and remove their experiences, why are ANY of their other experiences not banned? You’re telling me that INDEX had two of their experiences removed for using bots, but their other experiences remain in the contest? AND those experiences that were removed are only removed for these weeks, but are valid the rest of the challenge?

So in essence, what you’ve given everyone is the open invitation to cheat, use bot farms, and fake engagement in every way possible. Why? Because if you get caught there’s literally no consequences other than a slap on the wrist for that single experience.

People have no fear of using exploits because of this. I’m seriously shocked that this isn’t obvious to the team. And I know it’s a tough pill to swallow that you should ban these people because the player base is already so small, but I’m afraid you’re going to lose all of your legit studios and creators if you don’t ban these bad actors.

P.S. Also, if you’re reading this and you are one of the people sending me anonymous messages through my website and this forum, I would love to have a chat with you to get more information about these bot farms. I promise you will remain anonymous.
Hit me up on my email: tuschay@outlook.com

[DarckinITA]

That’s right, in my case my experience for the week in question 3/4 was EXPELLED.
For the following weeks, which the data has already been done, it is (for now) still good, precisely because the ranking has not yet been released.

Among other things, they publish rankings that are not exact, they do not respect the times they have chosen, not dictated by others, but by them and then we have to be the ones to check for them that the experiences are legitimate.
They have lost a lot of users since the end of the previous speed run, for those who remember or who participated know.
The same thing will happen to you, you will finally realize what TheSandbox is.

[VeePyre]

Hi Tuschay! Thanks for the feedback.

In this specific case, we recognise that our rules lacked clarity, particularly on working with guilds.

The experiences that were removed were those that showed strong signs of artificial engagement and were played by the guild.

As we have made clear in the updated rules, creators are now expected to vet guilds to ensure that they bring meaningful players and not bots. Failure to do so with the result that the guild brings botted engagement will now ultimately be the creator’s responsibility and will thus result in disqualification from the contest.

While this is true moving forward, it was the first case where action was taken on the grounds of dealing with guilds who provided artificial engagement.

We want to remain fair and just to everyone - also those who are being investigated for various reasons. In this case, our rules on this topic were not made clear, and the creator is granted the benefit of the doubt as there is no evidence that they were aware that the guild would bring artificial engagement to their experiences.

Now that the rule is clear, we expect everyone to uphold these and will take more strict action moving forward.

I hope this answers your concerns in this regard

[VeePyre]

Thanks for your feedback and positivity, Adam

Leaderboards are, indeed, a highly requested and very impactful tool for creators. I am currently trying to see how we can move this along faster, along with other tools.

Happy to hear more about which tools would be most impactful for creators! While I’m hoping to capture feedback on this in a more organised manner soon, please feel free to share your thoughts here!

[BagOGames]

Hi @VeePyre! When will the reward be distributed? Thanks much!

[DarckinITA]

Sure example “don’t ban “hj dusini eu 883773” who is first in the rankings with a time of 00.25s of a Bomkus race” but you know what the Guilds do and above all the Guilds use BOTs…
But for what?
I was left with the idea that to enter an experience you had to physically have a computer and a game account, and not use your mind.
So the removed experiences were the ones where they used the most BOTs?
Or did they use artificial intelligence to obtain those results?
You also specify that the deleted experiences are those played by the guild, what does this mean?
You have lost players, this is true, but now the category has changed, first it was the players, now it is the Studios who will then make people talk about this competition.